qevlarr,
@qevlarr@lemmy.world avatar

OP goes off the rails. Calm down, Javert. Assange was persecuted for his journalism. It’s as clear as day

Rapidcreek,

That’s funny. And delusional.

Linkerbaan,
@Linkerbaan@lemmy.world avatar

“When Exposing a Crime is Treated as Committing a Crime, You Are Ruled By Criminals.”

wurzelgummidge,

Sounds to me like they don’t really have anything on him but if they can get him to admit something they won’t look so much like the bags of shit they really are.

tsonfeir,
@tsonfeir@lemm.ee avatar

If they are serious about it, this would be great for him. He has been kicked around for his “crime” enough to count towards his sentence.

ShellMonkey,
@ShellMonkey@lemmy.socdojo.com avatar

I can’t properly express the irony involved in the Trump administration looking to charge Assange (who some claims is a Russian actor, which in itself would put him and Trump on the same team) when the ex-president is now charged with the same line of indictments for keeping classified docs as bathroom reading material…

Rapidcreek, (edited )

Not quite. The big thing they have on Assange is that he helped Chelsea Manning break into US databases, which is not only a computer crime but espionage. In any case, according to the WSJ prosecutors see diminishing odds that he would serve much more time even if he were convicted in the US.

phoneymouse,

Well the threat of prosecution sure has made his life hell for a long time.

Rapidcreek,

Assange is not your hero

livus,

Doesn’t matter. Human rights are inalienable.

Rapidcreek,

Assange put himself in his situation, it wasn’t done to him. He put himself in isolation rather than answer a rape investigation and once he jumped bail ended up where he is today. He fought the law and the law won. He has years of his life to show for it. Any suffering he had was his own doing.

livus,

None of that is relevant to me. Even leaving aside the question of whether what he did was journalism or espionage, he still should not be subject to extradition to a country with a track record of punishment that amounts to torture.

Given that all large nations spy on one another it’s a bit ridiculous to start extraditing each others’ spies, nor does the US try to. This is probably motivated by the whistleblowing.

Rapidcreek,

The law was being followed. A sealed indictment from a grand jury awaits Assange in the US. And it’s pretty common for any country to seek extradition in such a case. You simply don’t like that a case was made in the first place.

livus,

That argument is suspiciously vlose to No True Scotsman.

Sealed indictments and secret courts are all part of the reason I would oppose anyone being extradited to the US for political crimes.

Guantanamo is a massive international human rights violation that dragged on for over a decade. It’s not a country any of us should extradite non-US citizens to. Or even them, probably.

Rapidcreek,

Grand Juries are fairly common in our system.

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

>Any suffering he had was his own doing.

no. this is a problem of government overreach.

Rapidcreek,

So now it’s over reach to prosecute or even investigate people who brake the law.

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

it's overreach to create a false pretext for a war. it's overreach to murder journalists. it's overreach to cover it up. and it's overreach to prosecute the journalists who expose it.

Rapidcreek,

It’s not false, it’s the law. Geeeez

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

this is incoherent with what i said.

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

if the law says what assange did was wrong, the law is wrong.

free people have a duty regarding unjust laws.

Rapidcreek,

The law is wrong? Famous last words by many a criminal.

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

since there have been laws there have been criminals.

Rapidcreek,

You’ve got that backwards

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

no, laws make criminals.

Rapidcreek,

That’s not the way civilization developed. People do bad things, villages make rules that you can’t do that bad thing so it doesn’t happen again.

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

laws don't stop crime. they create it.

Rapidcreek,

Ok

Adanisi,
@Adanisi@lemmy.zip avatar

Whistleblowers should not be prosecuted.

Unless you’re okay with war crimes done by your precious United States?

Rapidcreek,

He was put in jail for jumping bail. Does he have the right to do that?.

Adanisi,
@Adanisi@lemmy.zip avatar

No. However don’t pretend for a second that the US wanting to extradite him has anything to do with that.

Rapidcreek,

I think the sealed indictment is registered in Federal Court.

bigMouthCommie,
@bigMouthCommie@kolektiva.social avatar

yes, he is.

ShellMonkey, (edited )
@ShellMonkey@lemmy.socdojo.com avatar

Yeah not exactly, but both in the same theme of possessing in one way or another docs they’re not supposed to have.

ShepherdPie,

I think you could liken it to robbing a bank to obtain money versus scamming a bunch of elderly people to obtain money. Both give you the same end result but each crime is treated differently.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • world@lemmy.world
  • fightinggames
  • All magazines