My all time favourite has to be The Return of the Obra Dinn. In my opnion it is the single best detective game. Not only is the narrative very captivating, but the deduction process cant be brute forced. It simply is a master piece.
It's been so long since I've played I don't think I can offer much useful advice. What I can say is that sometimes the game can be a bit finicky with causes of death. Impaled vs stabbed. So mb try switching those where it seems logical
Give me your favorite indie games! (lemmy.ml)
Haha I'm totally not doing this just to find and play a great underrated indie game. ^^